University of Natural Resources and Life Sciences, Vienna (BOKU) - Research portal

Selected Publication:

Friess, JL; Lalyer, CR; Giese, B; Simon, S; Otto, M.
(2023): Review of gene drive modelling and implications for risk assessment of gene drive organisms
ECOL MODEL. 2023; 478, 110285 FullText FullText_BOKU

Abstract:
Synthetic gene drive (GD) systems constitute a form of novel invasive environmental biotechnology with far-reaching consequences beyond those of other known genetically modified organisms (GMOs). During the last 10 years, the development of GD systems has been closely linked to mathematical modelling which can provide feedback on how to achieve gene drive spread but also may be used to predict the ecological consequences of a gene drive release. GMOs, thus also GD systems, need to pass an environmental risk assessment (ERA) prior to a release into the environment. Models in this respect may play an important role because a release of GD or-ganisms, even at a small scale, may not be reversible.In our review, we analyse the scope and structure of existing models to examine how they may assist the ERA. Our analysis reveals that a majority of models so far are deterministic, non-spatial and not tailored for a specific target organism. Models often use simplified assumptions on the biology of the species and seem to be made to test the effectiveness of the drive. Few models go beyond this and verify whether model predictions may be realistic under field conditions. We identified four advanced models that we judged to be the most ecologically realistic and compared the implemented parameters with ERA requirements by the European Food Safety Au-thority (EFSA) and World Health Organization (WHO) for genetically modified insects and mosquitoes. Although a number of abiotic and biotic factors are already considered in these models, mating-related factors and traits relevant to the interactions between the GMO and target organisms and with other species are largely excluded. Overall, our results show that biological and ecological realism are still poorly realized in current models and that most models aim to predict efficacy rather than ecological effects. Given the complexity of natural eco-systems, it may not be possible to compile a single model to cover all complexities. Thus, models should be further developed with the purpose to assist specific questions related to the risk assessment of GDs. Moreover, uncertainty will be a key issue for any model used in RA and we see the need to improve this aspect when modelling gene drives.
Authors BOKU Wien:
FrieƟ Johannes Ludwig
Giese Bernd Moritz
Lalyer Carina Roberta

Find related publications in this database (Keywords)
Gene drive
Modelling
Risk assessment
Uncertainty
Ecological factors


Altmetric:
© BOKU Wien Imprint